Adobe drops software sales in favor of subscriptions

Earlier today, Adobe announced a major change in strategic direction. Its Creative Suites, which bundle software such as Photoshop, Dreamweaver, Illustrator, Premiere Pro and After Effects into multiple packages for applications such as video post-production and web design, will be discontinued as of June, when the company introduces the next version of its Creative Cloud service. CS6, the current version of Adobe's Creative Suite, will remain on the market in both physical and downloadable versions, but will not be updated. In addition, individual applications will only be available in physical and downloadable versions in their CS6 form. As of June, the only way to get the latest version of Adobe's software will be to subscribe to either the complete Creative Cloud or to individual applications.

As with the current version of Creative Cloud, the new version will be priced at $49.99/month, and individual applications will be priced at $19.99/month. Existing Adobe customers who own either a complete copy of Creative Suite 3 or greater, or one of the applications in Creative Suite 3 or greater, can take advantage of three different pricing models:

• They can license individual applications for $9.99/month.
• If they own CS6, they can license the complete Creative Cloud collection for $19.99/month.
• If they own CS3, CS4, CS5 or CS5.5, they can license the complete Creative Cloud collection for $29.99/month.

After the first year, the price of individual applications will increase to $19.99/month, and the price of Creative Cloud will increase to $49.99/month.

Customers who use most of Adobe's applications, such as those in the former Production and Master Creative Suite collections, will end up saving money with Creative Cloud versus buying annual updates. On the other hand, customers who use fewer applications, such as those in the Design and Web Creative Suite collections, and customers who've typically skipped versions of Creative Suite in the past, will end up paying more on an annual basis for Creative Cloud subscriptions.

As it stands today, Creative Cloud is a good deal for many Adobe customers, but what we don't know are Adobe's future pricing plans. What's $49.99/month this year could be considerably more in a few years. My sense is that there's going to be a lot of resistance to the end of Adobe's Creative Suites and individual purchase options, and a fair number of creative professionals will begin evaluating open source and lower-cost replacements for Adobe's software.

Adobe is onto something with Creative Cloud

Adobe has started accepting pre-orders for CS6 Creative Cloud, its software subscription program. Everything that's been in Adobe's previous Creative Suites, plus a number of new applications that are either being released from or are still in Adobe Labs beta, and all of Adobe's tablet apps, are included in one monthly subscription. Month-to-month subscriptions are $75/month; annual subscriptions are $49.99/month. Prior purchasers of any version of Creative Suite from 3 or above qualify for a discount on the first-year subscription, which brings the price down to $29.99/month.

There were many complaints when Adobe first announced its plan to move to subscription pricing. The fear was that subscriptions would cost more than purchasing software outright--and in some cases, the fears were well-placed: Upgrading from CS5.5 Master Collection, which is the equivalent of Creative Cloud, costs $525, less than the $600 annual price of Creative Cloud before the first-year discount. However, if you skipped version 5.5 and stayed with version 5, the upgrade price is $1,049.00. Upgrades from earlier versions of Creative Suite are even more expensive.

The $29.99/month discounted first-year subscription price is a powerful incentive for Creative Suite users to switch to Creative Cloud. Adobe hopes that it can convince enough people to switch to Creative Cloud that eventually, it will no longer be economic for people to upgrade their packaged software. There's nothing keeping Adobe from raising prices once they get a critical mass of CS users to switch, of course. However, it looks like Adobe is willing to take a chance that lower prices will result in more total users. In addition, the company may be counting on the psychological benefit of a fairly low monthly payment versus a one-time big purchase to get into or upgrade Creative Suite. A completely new Creative Cloud user will get the equivalent of  $2,599 worth of software for a first-month payment of $50 on the annual plan.

My bet is that Adobe's pricing is going to bring in many more users, and it's going to put additional pressure on Avid, and especially Apple.