Here's the table of overall ratings for the 13 news organizations:
Overall, the most trusted news sources are local TV news and CBS' "60 Minutes", and the least trusted sources are The New York Times, Fox News and USA Today. Many of the reports on Pew's study stop at that point, but they miss the real story: There are huge differences between how Democrats, Republicans and independents trust news sources:
- Democrats trust everyone except Fox News. Every news source except Fox gets a positive believability rating.
- Democrats rate "60 Minutes", ABC News and CBS News (tie), CNN, NBC News and local TV news as most believable.
- Republicans only trust local TV news, Fox News, The Wall Street Journal, and (just barely) "60 Minutes" and USA Today. They distrust every other news source.
- Even though Republicans trust Fox News the second-most, its believability rating has fallen 10 points in two years, from 77% in 2010 to 67% now.
- Republicans and Democrats are closest in their perceptions of local TV news, USA Today and The Wall Street Journal.
- Independents typically fall between Democrats and Republicans--they're less enthusiastic about news sources in general than Democrats, but less pessimistic than Republicans. "60 Minutes", local TV news, The Wall Street Journal, CNN, ABC News and NPR (tie), the respondents' daily local newspaper they know best and CBS News are the news organizations that rate positively with independents.
This is why the overall ratings that lead the survey, while correct, are very misleading about what the survey actually found. The real takeaways are:
- Political views make a huge difference as to people's overall perceptions of news believability and media preferences.
- Republicans, at least in this survey, are too closed to news and opinions that might conflict with their world views.
- Democrats, again in this survey at least, are too trusting of the news they get from most outlets, and perhaps don't recognize that cuts in newsroom budgets since 2008 have led to a deterioration in the quality of news and opinions from most news organizations.
- Independents are the most cynical about believability across most news outlets, and probably represent the best balance of belief and skepticism.